Why this article is important: Broaden your client base by learning how to offer services as a sales or leasing agent for income property investors. This article reviews the required disclosures and forms used in a commercial real estate transaction in California.

Required forms for commercial property sales

Statutory rules govern commercial property transactions, requiring various disclosures and forms be used.

The legal definition of commercial property is any real property except:

  • one-to-four unit single-family residential (SFR) property;
  • public housing units;
  • mobilehomes; and
  • vacant land. [CC 2079.13(c)]

In practice, commercial property falls into the following income property categories:

  • office;
  • retail;
  • multi-family;
  • industrial; and
  • mixed use.

Representation agreements for every employment

A buyer agent must enter into a written representation agreement with their buyer client when the agent — in expectation of earning a fee — begins to assist their buyer-client to locate and acquire an interest in any type of real estate. [Calif. Civil Code §1670.50(a); See RPI Form 103.1 and 103.2]

The written Representation Agreement is entered into by the agent:

  • as soon as practicable (ASAP) after determining the agent is to represent the prospective client; and
  • always before the buyer or tenant signs an offer to acquire an interest in any type of property the agent submits on behalf of the client when they expect to earn a fee. [CC §1670.50(a)]

These rules are triggered by a broker undertaking the obligations to represent a buyer for any type of real estate, including:

  • SFR property;
  • multi-unit residential property with greater than four dwelling units;
  • commercial property;
  • raw land;
  • a ground lease coupled with improvements; and
  • mobilehomes classified as real estate. [CC §2079.13]

A buyer representation agreement is required, as noted, when the client seeks to acquire an interest in real estate. This covers clients seeking to acquire ownership of a fee simple interest in a property as a buyer, as well as ownership of a leasehold interest in property as a tenant.

Both involve the grant of an ownership interest in real estate with the right of possession, unlike a mortgage holder’s lien as a security interest in either a fee or leasehold estate owned by the borrower.

The commercial property agent uses the Buyer Representation Agreement form for employment by a buyer-client to acquire a fee simple interest (or leasehold) in property other than a one-to-four unit residential property, such as an investor seeking an income-producing property or a buyer-occupant user of a business or farming property. [See RPI Form 154, 158-1 and 159]

When representing an income-property owner to market property for lease and locate a tenant, the agent uses a Landlord Representation Agreement to negotiate the terms of their employment. [See RPI Form 106]

This form is used when a broker is employed as the sole agent to exclusively represent a commercial property landlord to solicit prospective tenants and negotiate a lease of the real estate. In the alternative, the form covers earning a fee in the likelihood a sale of fee simple ownership results. [Calif. Business & Professions Code §10176(f); See RPI Form 106]

Likewise, when representing a tenant seeking to lease commercial space, the agent uses a Tenant Representation Agreement to document their employment when the agent expects to earn a fee. Here, the agent is retained as the tenant’s sole agent to locate suitable property and negotiate the terms and conditions to acquire a leasehold or, alternatively, a fee interest. [Calif. Civil Code §1670.50; See RPI Forms 105.1, 105.2]

Editor’s note: Rights to acquire fee ownership by a client tenant, evidenced in lease agreement addendums, include options to buy and the right of first refusal. On the tenant’s exercise of these rights, the fee interest must be covered as part of the employment in the tenant representation agreement when the tenant agent expects to earn a fee at the time of exercise.  

Related article:

Form-of-the-Week: Commercial lease agreement addenda — Forms 552-6, 552-7 and 552-8

Disclosures made by an owner of commercial property

As with all types of real property in California, any seller or their seller agent marketing a commercial property for sale or lease must disclose material facts about the property. These disclosures are written notices, delivered to prospective buyers and tenants ASAP, and always before entering into a transaction. They address various property and transaction conditions which might adversely affect a buyer’s or tenant’s decision to acquire an interest in the property – fee simple or leasehold.

While the generic form created for the Natural Hazard Disclosure (NHD) Statement is used for disclosures in SFR transactions but is not mandated for use when delivering non-residential property disclosures, the same disclosures are required in all commercial transactions. The logical method for making the disclosures is simply to use the SFR form as the default practice when representing an owner. [See RPI Form 314]

The owner of a commercial property and their agent makes NHD disclosures to prospective buyers and tenants when a property is located within any of the following areas or zones:

  • a special flood hazard area as designated by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA);
  • an area of potential flooding as shown on an inundation map;
  • a very high fire hazard severity zone;
  • a state responsibility area located within a wildland area that may contain substantial wildfire risks and hazards;
  • a delineated earthquake fault zone; [See RPI Form 315-1] or
  • a seismic hazard zone. [Calif. Government Code §§§8589.3(a); 8589.4(a); 51183.5(a); Calif. Public Resources Code §§§4136(a); 2621.9(a); 2694(a)]

These NHD disclosures in residential and commercial transactions are required when:

  • the owner or their agent has knowledge the property is located within the area or zone requiring disclosure; or
  • the local government has compiled and posted a list or map of parcels located within the area(s) or zone(s). [Gov C §§§8589.3(b); 8589.4(b); 51183.5(b); PRC §§§4136(b) 2621.9(b); 2694(b)]

Editor’s note: When the owner or their agent lacks knowledge about whether NHD conditions exist, one or the other, or a third party NHD report needs to check out what the local government agencies have posted for NHD areas and zones covering the property.

Further, the hazard disclosures made by the seller agent must also inform the potential buyers or tenants when special duties are imposed on them to maintain a property located within a hazardous zone or area.

The failure to disclose these hazardous zone or area conditions imposed on ownership is not grounds for the buyer or tenant to nullify the transaction. However, an owner and their agent who willfully or negligently fail to disclose the property’s location within any of the hazardous zones or areas is liable for buyer or tenant losses when the owner’s agent fails to make the NHD disclosures. [Gov C §§§8589.3(e); 8589.4(e); 51183.5(e); PRC §§§4136(e) 2621.9(e); 2694(e)]

Further, for a commercial building constructed before January 1, 1975 with unreinforced masonry and wood frame floors or roofs, the seller and thus the seller agent provides prospective buyers and tenants a copy of the Commercial Property Owner’s Guide to Earthquake Safety. This disclosure is downloaded from the Seismic Safety Commission. [Gov C §8875.6]

When the seller provides the Owner’s Guide, neither the seller/landlord nor their broker is required to provide additional information about geologic and seismic hazards that may affect the property. [CC §2079.9(a)]

Editor’s note — Local cities and counties may additionally require their own disclosures.

Related article:

Form-of-the-Week: Residential Earthquake Hazards Report and Commercial Property Earthquake Disclosure Report – Forms 315 and 315-1

Flood insurance disclosure

When Federal disaster relief assistance has been provided to commercial property located in a flood disaster area — and the assistance was accepted on the condition the owner obtain flood insurance for the property — the seller must in writing notify the buyer and a tenant entering into a net lease of the need to:

  • obtain flood insurance; and
  • maintain flood insurance on the property. [42 United States Code §5154a(b)(1)]

This flood insurance requirement information is provided ASAP and never later than the close of escrow, the one exception to disclosures required before entering into an agreement to buy or lease. [42 USC §5154a(b)(1)]

Water heater disclosure

A seller of commercial property containing a water heater needs to certify the water heater(s) complies with earthquake safety regulations. The seller agent has the duty to:

  • advise the seller of this required disclosure; and
  • deliver the compliance information to prospective buyers and tenants.

Any water heater with a capacity of no more than 120 gallons needs to be braced, anchored or strapped to resist displacement due to an earthquake. [Calif. Health & Safety Code §19211(a); (d)]

Hazardous substances disclosures

The commercial property owner or their agent needs to provide notice to prospective buyers and tenants when the property has been contaminated by methamphetamine laboratory activity. [Health & S C §25400.28]

Here too, as with all disclosures, the agent representing the owner has the duty to deliver the disclosure ASAP to prospective users on commencement of negotiations and always before entering into an agreement, be they buyers or tenants.

The owner and thus their agent also needs to inform the buyer or tenant whether or not they have knowledge of the release of any hazardous substances on the property. [Health & S C §78700]

Disclosing death on the property

A death occurring on a property, and the manner of the death, are always material facts disclosed ASAP to potential buyers or tenants when:

  • the death occurred within three years prior to the date of the offer to purchase or lease; or
  • the death at any time in the past affects the property’s value or desirability to the buyer or tenant. [Calif. Civil Code §1710.2]

However, neither the seller, landlord nor the agent is required to disclose that an occupant of the property was afflicted with or died from AIDS, regardless of when the death occurred. [CC §1710.2(a)]

Related article:

When to Disclose a Death on a Property

 

Regardless of whether a death occurred within three years of the buyer submitting a purchase offer, on direct inquiry into deaths by the buyer or their agent, the seller agent discloses their knowledge of deaths at any time on the real estate. [CC §1710.2(d)]

Consider a buyer who asks the sellers agent whether any deaths occurred on the property.

No matter when the death occurred, on direct inquiry, the seller agent discloses their knowledge of the existence of any deaths which occurred on the real estate. [CC §1710.2(d)]

An intentional misrepresentation or concealment of a known fact after a buyer makes a direct inquiry is:

  • a breach of the seller agent’s general duty owed to the buyer to truthfully respond when the seller agent represents the seller exclusively; or
  • a breach of the buyer agent’s specific duty owed the buyer as the buyer’s advisor in the transaction. [CC §1710.2(d)]

Further, an inquiry by the buyer into deaths indicates a death on the premises is a fact which might affect the buyer’s use and enjoyment of the property. Thus, a buyer expressing an interest in deaths occurring on the property is a material fact – it might affect their decision to acquire an ownership interest in the property.

On an inquiry into deaths by a buyer, an affirmative duty is imposed on the buyer agent to either:

  • investigate the death and advise the buyer-client; or
  • recommend an investigation by the buyer before an offer is made, or include a further-approval contingency on the subject of death in the buyer’s offer.

A seller agent who on an inquiry discloses they do not know whether a death occurred on the real estate, is to hand the buyer a memorandum stating:

  • the buyer has made an inquiry about deaths on the property;
  • the agent has disclosed all their knowledge concerning the inquiry; and
  • whether the agent or others will further investigate and report any deaths on the property.

Agency Law Disclosure

The Agency Law Disclosure is presented to all clients by the agent they employ at the time they enter into a representation agreement to sell, buy, exchange or lease for a term greater than one year:

  • single family residential property;
  • multi-unit residential property with more than four dwelling units;
  • commercial property;
  • vacant land;
  • a ground lease coupled with improvements; or
  • manufactured homes. [CC §§2079.13(j); 2079.14]

The agency law disclosure describes the various agency roles licensees undertake on behalf of their client and other participants in a real estate transaction.

However, the Agency Law Disclosure is not required on real estate related negotiations and agreements concerning:

  • property management;
  • mortgage arrangements; and
  • month-to-month rental agreements and lease agreements for a one year term or less.

At its core, the Agency Law Disclosure form is a restatement of existing agency codes and case law on agency relationships in all real estate transactions and leases exceeding a one year term.

RPI publishes Agency Law Disclosure forms for transactions involving:

Disclosing dual agency

As with any type real estate, agents disclose dual agency and conflicts of interest to all participants in the transaction immediately upon creation of the dual agency.

A dual agency is a conflict of interest — of the most basic variety. Thus, the broker needs written consent from both the seller/landlord and the buyer/tenant before the broker or their agents may further act on behalf of either the seller- or buyer-client regarding any aspect of a property transaction. [Calif. Civil Code §2079.13(d); See RPI Form 117]

The failure of the broker to promptly disclose a dual agency conflict subjects the broker to:

  • inability to collect their broker fee;
  • liability for money losses incurred by the buyer- and seller-clients; and
  • disciplinary action by the Department of Real Estate (DRE) on receipt of a complaint. [Calif. Business and Professions Code §10176(d)]

Other conflicts of interest the agent discloses may arise when the broker:

  • has a pre-existing relationship with another person involved in the transaction due to a kinship, employment, partnership, common membership, religious affiliation, civic ties, or any other deep-rooted socio-economic context; and
  • that relationship might hinder their ability to fully represent the needs of their client.

Related article:

Buyer representation, dual agency and double ending

Offering tax advice: part of an agent’s fiduciary duty?

DRE licensees acting as an agent owe a general duty to disclose known material facts about a property to all participants in the transaction. Brokers and their agents further owe their clients a specific duty to advise on the consequences of those material facts and the documentation in the transaction.

Here, a broker employed to sell commercial property who determines the tax aspects of a sales transaction might affect their client’s decisions in the handling of a transaction has a specific fiduciary duty to disclose their knowledge on the tax implications — a material fact. A prudent seller broker extends their guidance beyond mere tax information to help their client achieve the tax outcome sought by the client, such as structuring a §1031 reinvestment plan. When the agent is employed to locate the replacement property, they must enter into a buyer representation agreement when they expect to earn a fee on the additional transaction.

Understand that tax aspects of a transaction are a material fact to a client selling or buying property which can qualify as a §1031 transaction when the client is considering acquiring other property with the sales proceeds or vice versa in a §1031 parking arrangement.   Here, as a matter of basic competency, a broker or agent handling the sale needs to possess an understanding of the fundamental tax concepts affecting the sale — and disclose the extent and basis for their knowledge to their client.

As an exception to the general rule of advising a client, a seller agent employed to market a one-to-four unit residential property has no duty to inform their seller-client about the income tax aspects of a sale of their property. However, on a direct inquiry from their SFR client, the agent is required to respond honestly and to the best of their knowledge. [Carleton v. Tortosa (1993) 14 CA4th 745]

Related article:

The truth about giving tax advice to clients