Migratory lockdown: underwater homeowners confined

This article explains the effect of negative equity on homeowner mobility, identifies the factor which influence migration and advises how brokers and agents can counsel homeowners considering relocating under the conditions of this Lesser Depression.

The great migration debate

The ability to pack up, pick up and move on in search of new beginnings is a quintessential part of the American spirit. Yet the frost of the current Lesser Depression is changing this; fences are being drawn ever more tightly around the once highly mobile American and nothing explains the present epidemic of migratory lockdown more than the negative equity condition which afflicts real estate.

Migration tends to be procyclical, that is, it rises during periods of economic expansion and falls during periods of economic recession.  Economists agree on this matter, however lately they have disagreed over the matter of whether negative equity keeps a homeowner from moving. This condition, known as house lock, and which we reference as a statewide and nationwide occurrence called migratory lockdown, is debated in studies issued by the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis (FRBM), the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (FRBC) and the Federal Reserve Board of Governors (FRBG). Largely, researchers at those institutions argue negative equity has little to no bearing on a homeowner’s ability to move. [For more information on the argument against house lock, see the December 2010 FRBM paper, Negative Equity Does Not Reduce Homeowners’ Mobility, the September 2011 FRBC paper, How much has house lock affected mobility and the unemployment rate? and the May 2011 FRBG paper, Internal Migration in the United States.]

End of free preview

The rest of this content is only available to first tuesday Members. If you are a current first tuesday Member, please login above.

Not a current Member? For only $29.50, our Annual Membership includes access to:

  • the first tuesday journal;
  • over 350 first tuesday real estate forms;
  • over 35 FARM letters; and
  • a 16-book reference library and more!

To view samples or sign up, visit firsttuesday.us!

Latest Comments
  1. Justin Haines
    Reply -
  2. Steve
    Reply -

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>